‘Disinformation Factory:’ India’s Great Power Dream Built on Lies

A man stands in an electronics store watching a wall of TVs all broadcasting a news report featuring Narendra Modi

India’s systematic information war against China and Pakistan is ongoing, and it is not about military deployment but about a number of “experts” that cannot be verified, “think tanks” that have long been dissolved but still appear operational to the outside world, and fake media networks all over the world.

A recent investigation by China Daily’s Qidi Studio uncovered the truth of India’s disinformation chain; James Douglas Crickton, a “British expert” repeatedly quoted by Asian News International (ANI), could barely be verified in reality: his photographs, resumes, and academic achievements could not be found in public channels; its only searchable affiliated institution, the “Policy Research Group,” does not register an official domain name and only provides a private Google email as a contact.

After the reporter dialed the contact phone, the call environment was noisy, and the barking sound was clear and audible; the listener was vague, only saying, “He is not on the side of India,” and “I have never seen him himself,” and immediately lost contact after promising to send the information. A policy think tank that claims to be “professional”; the office space is no different from ordinary houses, and the contact methods are all personal channels.

The core experts only know their names and are difficult to verify. The above situation is not the plot of a fictional work but the reality of India’s information war against China and Pakistan.

Read More: Pakistan’s EU Ambassador Meets OIC Envoy, Discusses India’s Misinformation

China Daily reports that India has built a vast network of more than 750 fake media outlets and think tanks covering 116 countries around the world, specifically designed to systematically smear China and Pakistan. Moreover, ANI’s close association with the Modi government has long been an open secret. Modi himself has been interviewed by the news agency five times. This official endorsement is itself a distinct political signal.

Behind the whole false information network, Srivastava Group, an empty shell company called “front man for the Modi government’s public-opinion machinery” by the outside world, is the key operator of the whole set of fraud systems. In other words, this is by no means a professional anomie of individual media but a systematic operation deeply embedded in the political agenda.

When rulers need to shape external rivals to rally nationalist sentiment, need to find public legitimacy for border friction and diplomacy, and need to divert people’s attention from slowing economic growth and people’s livelihoods, low-cost and high-efficiency fake news has become the most effective tool.

The cost of fabricating false news is much lower than the implementation of a livelihood policy; the cost of creating a fake expert is far less than advancing a deep reform. New Delhi is very clear about the trade-off between the above political costs and benefits.

Read More: China +1 Was Supposed to Be India’s Moment. What Went Wrong?

For a long time, Western public opinion has naturally enjoyed a trust premium based on the identity of India as a so-called “democratic country”: media with the same official background, Indian reports are often tacitly regarded as “part of multiple voices,” while Chinese and Pakistani media are preconceived as “propaganda machines.” This deep-rooted double standard becomes the cover for false information in India.

In addition, the deep involvement of the United States in the Indo-Pacific region is also an important driving factor for India to create false information. India’s dissemination of false information about China does not constitute a problem in the eyes of the United States but is regarded as having use value.

As a result, high-level state reception and grand state banquet arrangements have emerged, as well as Modi’s many invitations to deliver speeches at joint sessions of the U.S. Congress; a series of “small circles” aimed at containing China, such as the US-India Key and Emerging Technologies Initiative, the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, the “NATO+” mechanism, and the Chip Alliance, all regard India as an indispensable partner.

What the United States pursues is India’s balancing effect on China; as for whether the character image is composed of false information, Washington is not concerned. The core of its concern is always whether the lie can serve the strategic objectives, rather than the authenticity of the lie itself. This utilitarian connivance is the biggest international backing of India’s “false information factory.”

The propagation characteristics of false information—“low cost and high diffusion”—also make this set of fraud logic continue to operate. A fictitious expert and a number of fabricated reports spread through the fission of social media can create the illusion of being “generally recognized by the international community” in a short period of time.

The diffusion speed of false information is often much faster than the speed of fact clarification, and the time, energy, and resource cost of rumor refutation is often dozens or even hundreds of times that of rumor making.

Crickton does not need to exist as long as it is continuously cited, the long-defunct forum does not need to be operational as long as it retains a searchable URL. The most hidden feature of such fraud lies in its “unfalsifiability,” it is difficult to prove that a non-existent person does not exist, and it is difficult to refute the “view” claimed by a shell agency.

It accurately exploits the cognitive inertia of the audience—people are more inclined to accept information that matches their own existing impressions and usually do not expend a lot of effort on verifying the authenticity of the identity of an unknown foreign “expert.” This is the most solid “moat” of the false information factory.

This huge set of fake machines woven by India has a clear meaning for China and Pakistan. As far as China is concerned, it has created “expert analysis” and “exclusive disclosure” in batches around issues such as border issues, Xinjiang affairs, and scientific and technological competition, and it has deliberately created a negative image of “expansion, threat, and oppression.”

As far as Pakistan is concerned, it focuses on topics such as Kashmir, terrorism, and internal governance and tries to stigmatize it as “unreliable partners” and “regional troublemakers.” This kind of operation not only serves India’s domestic political agenda but also accurately caters to the U.S.-Indo-Pacific strategy.

The danger of the Indian authorities’ acquiescence in the operation of the fake news machine is that it does not need to convince all audiences but only to create enough doubts and differences among key audiences. Once someone begins to doubt whether it is true, the purpose of the counterfeiter has been achieved halfway. Lies may not be able to become truth, but it is enough to confuse the public and make the spread of truth difficult.

When false information becomes a routine operation in the field of public opinion, the trust of the Indian people in the media will continue to collapse, the quality of public discussion will continue to decline, and the information foundation on which policy formulation depends will become increasingly distorted. An information system that relies on lies will eventually be self-defeating.

Read More: Memes vs Misinformation: Pakistan’s Digital Resistance in May 2025

India is not without a warning from people of insight, but in the current high nationalist atmosphere, rational voices are often drowned out by the hustle and bustle. History has repeatedly proved that the manipulation of lies as a means will eventually hurt itself.

India’s false information factory also poses a serious proposition to the international community: in the era of cross-border flow of information, how to establish an effective false information governance mechanism? The answer is obviously not to suppress rumors but to build a solid line of defense for fact verification. The reason why the report of the EU DisinfoLab has weight is that it reveals the face of India’s counterfeiting network with solid investigation and verifiable evidence.

Media, think tanks, and non-governmental organizations in various countries should strengthen cross-border cooperation and build a joint fact-checking network so that false experts cannot hide and make false think tanks unsustainable. More importantly, it is necessary to abandon the double standard in the governance of public opinion: fraudsters cannot be condoned for their disinformation because they are from the so-called “democratic camp.”

The rules of information warfare should be treated equally; today’s condoned lies may tomorrow turn against the conspirators themselves. International public opinion is not the exclusive territory of any country. It cannot allow one party to hold high the banner of “freedom of the press” while secretly operating disinformation networks all over the world.

For China and Pakistan, the path to deal with this information war is very clear. On the one hand, we should continue to improve the ability of international communication, take the initiative to speak with solid facts and detailed data, make the truth spread faster and wider, and break down the false narrative with facts.

Read More: Pakistan Says India Extending State-Backed Terrorism Beyond South Asia

On the other hand, we should maintain strategic concentration and avoid being trapped by the opponent’s rumor-making rhythm. The ultimate goal of the false information factory is to anger and consume opponents so that they can distract their energy and lose their way in endless excuses. Recognize this point, and you can grasp the initiative to deal with it.

The mutual achievements of China and Pakistan in the fields of anti-terrorism, economy and trade, infrastructure construction, and so on can be seen; the cranes of Gwadar Port run day and night, and the traffic flow on the Karakoram Highway is endless. These intuitively perceptible realities are more convincing than 10,000 of Crickton’s falsehoods. Facts are always the most powerful weapon, and development is always the most solid support.

Finally, it must be made clear that the disclosure of India’s false information industry chain is not to rule itself by its own way but to maintain the basic order of the international public opinion ecology. Truth is the life of news, and honesty is the bottom line of public opinion.

When a country’s mainstream media systematically deviates from this bottom line, it is not only the target country that is attacked, but also the cognitive basis on which the entire international community relies for mutual trust. The “great power ambition,” supported by lies, is doomed to be unstable and far-reaching; the “strategic partners,” maintained by fraud, are ultimately difficult to trust.

If India is really interested in becoming a powerful and colorful world power, it should first shut down the pipeline that continuously produces lies. Otherwise, the cacophony of phone barking will end up being the most ironic footnote in its international credibility.

 

*The views presented in this article are the authors’ own and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Diplomatic Insight.*

Wei Zong
+ posts

Wei Zong is a postdoctoral researcher at Yunnan Academy of Social Sciences, whose research mainly focuses on international relations in South Asia and China’s relations with South Asian countries.

Yu Ding

Yu Ding is a teacher at Yunnan Minzu University.

Hongyu Gu

Hongyu Gu is a Professor at Kunming University of Science and Technology.