When Thomas Paine published his famous pamphlet Common Sense in January 1776, his argument was remarkably simple yet politically revolutionary. He questioned the legitimacy of hereditary monarchy and challenged the idea that a distant king had the natural right to govern people living thousands of miles away.
Paine argued that the American colonies had every reason to determine their own political destiny rather than remain subordinate to the British Crown.
His pamphlet became an important intellectual catalyst for the American Revolution and helped popularize the cause of independence among ordinary colonists. Eventually, the thirteen colonies declared independence on July 4, 1776, laying the foundations of the United States of America.
Almost 250 years later, Paine’s argument continues to offer an interesting perspective on American politics. Although the political circumstances have changed considerably, the underlying question remains relevant: should political decisions serve the interests of ordinary citizens, or should they primarily serve established political, economic and ideological interests?
Read More: Reverse Identity Effect in Present-Day American Politics
Contemporary American elections demonstrate that voters continue to respond to political arguments that appeal to their everyday concerns. In this sense, Thomas Paine’s Common Sense remains relevant not merely as a historical document but as a continuing political principle.
The 2024 presidential election provides an interesting starting point. The contest between Democratic candidate Kamala Harris and Republican candidate Donald Trump resulted in a decisive electoral victory for Trump. He secured 312 electoral votes against Harris’s 226 and also won the national popular vote. Although several factors contributed to his victory, his campaign’s appeal to ordinary American concerns was particularly significant.
His slogan, ‘America First’, presented a straightforward political proposition: American resources and government policies should primarily serve American interests. His promises concerning immigration control, employment, domestic manufacturing, energy production and reducing foreign military commitments resonated with sections of the electorate.
For voters experiencing economic uncertainty, rising living costs and dissatisfaction with established political leadership, these arguments offered a seemingly practical alternative.
Trump’s electoral success therefore illustrates the political effectiveness of connecting national policy with the everyday concerns of citizens. However, an important distinction must be made: winning an election does not automatically establish that every policy proposed by the winning candidate represents common sense.
Rather, it demonstrates the importance of understanding public priorities and communicating political choices in terms that ordinary people can recognize.
Nevertheless, the subsequent political developments have also demonstrated the limitations of populist appeals. Policies involving extensive tariffs, confrontational foreign relations and territorial ambitions have generated questions about whether the pursuit of national interests is necessarily consistent with practical economic and diplomatic reasoning.
The controversy surrounding threats to annex Greenland and Canada, intervention in Venezuela and the military confrontation involving Iran illustrates how the language of national interest can become disconnected from the practical consequences of political decisions. Common sense, therefore, should also involve examining the long-term costs of government policies rather than merely their immediate political appeal.
A particularly interesting illustration emerged during the 2025 New York City mayoral election. Zohran Mamdani, a Democratic Socialist, defeated his opponents by building a campaign around affordability, housing, public transport and the cost of living. His campaign challenged the conventional assumption that electoral success in a major American city necessarily depended on established political networks and wealthy donors.
One notable controversy concerned his position on visiting Israel if elected mayor. While other mayoral candidates indicated their willingness to visit Israel, Mamdani questioned whether such a visit was necessary to fulfil his responsibilities towards New York’s Jewish population.
His argument was essentially that a mayor’s primary responsibility was to serve the people of New York rather than demonstrate political credentials through international visits. He maintained that representing Jewish New Yorkers required engaging with Jewish communities within the city itself.
Whether one agrees with Mamdani’s position on Israel or not, the underlying political argument is worth considering. A mayor is elected to govern a city and address the concerns of its residents. His or her effectiveness should consequently be assessed through public services, housing, affordability, security and municipal administration rather than symbolic diplomatic gestures alone.
This is an example of how an appeal to practical political responsibilities can challenge established political conventions.
The 2026 midterm elections provide another compelling illustration. Democratic candidates made significant gains in traditionally Republican territory, including Texas, South Carolina, Ohio and Mississippi. Their success was particularly noteworthy because these states had generally been considered difficult electoral environments for Democratic candidates.
Among the interesting political developments was the victory of Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan’s Senate election. Despite facing attacks questioning his political loyalties and attempts to associate him with religious extremism, El-Sayed successfully campaigned on universal healthcare, Medicare for All, reducing corporate influence in politics and addressing the concerns of ordinary Americans.
His victory demonstrated that voters could prioritize healthcare, economic security and public accountability over attempts to define candidates through controversial ideological labels.
His electoral success should not be interpreted as proof that all voters supported every aspect of his political ideology. Rather, it demonstrates that practical questions of healthcare affordability, economic security and political representation can become more important to voters than attempts to discredit candidates through personal or ideological attacks.
These developments also raise a broader question about the nature of contemporary American democracy. Is political competition increasingly determined by the traditional ideological divisions between Republicans and Democrats, or are voters becoming more concerned with which party can provide practical solutions to their problems?
American politics has traditionally been characterized by divisions between conservative and liberal constituencies, commonly described as red and blue states. However, contemporary political debates increasingly involve questions about the influence of corporate lobbying, wealthy political donors, organized interest groups and the role of powerful individuals such as Elon Musk.
Organizations such as AIPAC have also become subjects of debate concerning the influence of organized political advocacy on American foreign policy.
These developments do not necessarily mean that established political institutions have lost their influence. Rather, they highlight the growing importance of public accountability and the question of whose interests political representatives ultimately serve.
A political system that becomes excessively dependent on wealthy donors, powerful lobbying organizations or ideological commitments risks losing touch with the everyday concerns of ordinary citizens.
This is precisely where Thomas Paine’s political philosophy becomes relevant. His criticism of hereditary privilege was rooted in the belief that political authority should not be determined by birth, inherited status or traditional hierarchies. He challenged the assumption that established institutions deserved unquestioned obedience simply because they had existed for generations.
In contemporary America, the equivalent challenge is not necessarily directed against monarchy but against political complacency, institutional privilege and the concentration of influence. Citizens increasingly expect elected representatives to justify their decisions through tangible public benefits rather than ideological slogans or political symbolism.
Ultimately, the enduring relevance of Common Sense lies in its insistence that political authority must be justified through reason and public interest. Paine’s historical contribution was to challenge an established political order by appealing to the ordinary reasoning of ordinary people. Contemporary American politics demonstrates that this appeal has not disappeared.
Read More: Abdul El Sayed’s Victory: The Other America Strikes Back
Whether through Trump’s America First rhetoric, Mamdani’s emphasis on municipal responsibilities or El-Sayed’s campaign for affordable healthcare, successful political arguments frequently begin by identifying concerns that ordinary citizens consider important.
Nevertheless, common sense must go beyond electoral popularity. It must also demand consistency, accountability, sound judgment and an assessment of the long-term consequences of political decisions.
The ultimate lesson of Thomas Paine is therefore not that one political party possesses common sense while another lacks it. Rather, it is that no political institution, ideology or leader should be placed beyond public scrutiny. A democracy remains healthy when citizens retain the ability to question authority, evaluate policies independently and demand that government serves the public interest.
Almost two and a half centuries after its publication, Common Sense continues to remind Americans of a fundamental democratic principle: political power derives its legitimacy from the people, and its purpose must ultimately be their welfare.
*The views presented in this article are the authors’ own and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Diplomatic Insight.*

Idrees Khan
Idrees Khan holds a BS(Hons) degree in Government and Public Policy and is an alumnus of the SUSI exchange program at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. Currently, he is serving as Azerbaijan Youth ministry representative.











